Identifying Independent, Dependent and Controlled Variables
About this lesson
Students read short experiment descriptions in pairs and label the independent, dependent and controlled variables in each one, then write a testable question of their own. They practise a key skill for designing fair tests. You need four scenarios written on the board and scrap paper. It takes about 15 minutes.
- Grade
- 8
- Subject
- Science
- Time
- 15 min
- Prep
- 5 min
Objective
Students will correctly identify the independent, dependent and controlled variables in a described experiment and write a testable question that names each one.
Prep
5 min: write four short experiment scenarios on the board
Materials
- Whiteboard and markers
- Scrap paper
- Pencils
Steps
- Write these on the board: A) Plants get 0, 50 or 100 mL of water a day and height is measured in cm after 2 weeks. B) A toy car is released from ramps 10, 20 and 30 cm high and the rolling distance is measured. C) Sugar is stirred into water at 10, 30 and 50 °C and dissolving time is recorded. D) Paper airplanes with different wing widths are thrown and flight distance is measured in metres.
- Explain in one minute that the independent variable is what the scientist changes on purpose, the dependent variable is what gets measured, and controlled variables are everything kept the same so the test is fair. Model scenario A aloud as an example.
- Have pairs fold scrap paper into three columns labelled Change, Measure and Keep the Same, then fill them in for scenarios B, C and D, listing at least two controlled variables each (6 minutes).
- Call on pairs to share one scenario each, and ask the class to give a thumbs up or challenge any variable that is in the wrong column.
- For the last 2 minutes, each student writes one testable question in the form 'How does changing ___ affect ___?' and lists two things they would keep the same.
Quick Check
Collect the testable questions as exit slips and check that each one names a variable to change, a measurable result and at least two controlled variables.
Differentiation
Make it easier: Do scenario B together as a class and give pairs a word bank of possible controlled variables for C and D.
Make it harder: Ask pairs to rewrite one scenario with a flaw, such as two variables changing at once, and have another pair spot and fix it.
Good For
- Review
- Supply teacher
- Before lunch
- End of day