Sorting Primary and Secondary Sources
About this lesson
Children work in pairs to sort a list of everyday historical sources, such as diaries, photographs and textbooks, into primary and secondary sources. They practise explaining how close each source is to the event it describes. You only need a whiteboard list and scrap paper, and it takes about 12 minutes.
Objective
Students will classify historical sources as primary or secondary and justify each choice by explaining whether the creator was present at the time of the event.
Prep
5 min: write 8 numbered sources on the board: a soldier's diary from the war, a textbook chapter on ancient Egypt, a photo of a 1960s classroom, an encyclopedia entry on volcanoes, a grandparent's letter about their first job, a biography of a scientist, a map drawn by an explorer during the voyage, a documentary made this year about the first moon landing
Materials
- whiteboard and marker
- scrap paper
- pencils
Steps
- Explain that a primary source was made by someone who was there at the time, and a secondary source was made later by someone studying or retelling the event.
- Put students in pairs and have them write the numbers 1 to 8 on scrap paper, marking each source P for primary or S for secondary.
- Give pairs 4 minutes to sort, and ask them to choose one source they disagreed on or found tricky.
- Go through the list aloud, having pairs show P or S with their hands (fist for P, flat hand for S), and ask one pair to explain each answer using the question: was the creator there at the time?
- Finish by asking pairs to name one primary source from their own lives that a historian might use in 100 years, such as a birthday photo or a class journal.
Quick Check
Ask each student to tell a partner whether today's class attendance sheet is primary or secondary and give the reason.
Differentiation
Make it easier: Use only 5 clear-cut sources, such as a diary, a photo, a textbook, an encyclopedia and a letter, and do the first two together as a class.
Make it harder: Add tricky items, such as a newspaper article written years later that quotes an eyewitness, and have pairs explain why it could count as both.
Good For
- Before lunch
- End of day
- Supply teacher
- Review