Choosing a Hospital Site Using Map Distances and Criteria – Grade 7 Social Studies lesson plan
|
Social StudiesGrade 7

Choosing a Hospital Site Using Map Distances and Criteria

About this lesson

In this 50-minute Grade 7 lesson, small groups copy a fictional regional map onto grid paper, measure distances in kilometres, and weigh population, flood risk, road access and land cost to decide where a new hospital should go. Students practise spatial reasoning and evidence-based decision making. You need paper, rulers, markers, chart paper and a whiteboard.

Grade
7
Subject
Social Studies
Time
50 min

Objective

Students will evaluate three possible hospital locations using measured distances and geographic criteria, and justify a final choice with map evidence.

Materials

  • Plain or grid paper (one sheet per group)
  • Rulers with centimetre markings
  • Markers or coloured pencils
  • Chart paper for the group decision summary
  • Whiteboard and markers
  • Sticky notes

Hook

Ask students, 'If someone in your family needed emergency care right now, how long would it take to reach a hospital, and what might slow you down?' Collect quick answers on the whiteboard, such as distance, traffic, bad roads and weather. Explain that governments and planners must decide where to build important services, and today each group will act as a planning team making that decision.

Main Activity

Draw a 10 by 10 grid on the whiteboard where each square is 1 km and label these features with coordinates (across, up): Town A, population 12,000, at (2,8); Town B, population 5,000, at (8,7); Village C, population 2,000, at (5,2); a river running straight up and down along column 5, with everything within 1 km of it marked as a flood zone; and a main road running straight across along row 5. Mark three candidate hospital sites: Site 1 at (5,6), on the riverbank with cheap land; Site 2 at (3,6), on expensive farmland near the road; and Site 3 at (7,4), on cheap land that is 3 km from the nearest school bus route. In groups of three, with the roles of mapper, measurer and recorder, students copy the map at a scale of 1 cm = 1 km, use rulers to measure the straight-line distance from each site to each town, and calculate a 'travel load' for each site by multiplying each distance by that town's population in thousands and then adding the results. Groups then score each site from 1 to 3 on four criteria: travel load, flood safety, road access and land cost. They must agree on one site, even if no site wins on every criterion. Each group records its choice, scores and a two-sentence justification on chart paper, and the class does a gallery walk, leaving sticky-note questions or agreements on other groups' posters.

Discussion Questions

  1. Why might the site with the shortest total travel distance still be a poor choice?
  2. How did your group decide which criterion mattered most when the scores disagreed?
  3. Who benefits most and who benefits least from your group's chosen site, and is that fair?
  4. What other information would a real planning team want before making this decision?
  5. How might the best choice change if Village C grew to 10,000 people in twenty years?

Exit Ticket

On a slip of paper, name the site your group chose, give one piece of measured map evidence that supports it, and identify one trade-off your group accepted.

Differentiation

Support: Give struggling learners a partly completed map with the towns and river already drawn, plus a simple table with columns for Site, Distance to A, Distance to B, Distance to C and Travel Load. Allow distances to be rounded to the nearest whole kilometre, and pair these students with a supportive measurer who models the first measurement aloud.

Extension: Advanced learners add a second service, such as a fire station, that must be at least 4 km from the hospital and within 3 km of every town by road. They test whether any location on the grid meets all conditions, then write a short memo to the town council explaining their recommendation and its limits.

Similar Lessons